Love, Murder, and Hairballs: The Truth Behind Your Cat’s ‘Gifts’

A Pet Parent’s Guide from Dogs On The Run

Have you ever found a “gift” from your feline friend—a mouse, a bird, or some other unlucky creature—waiting for you at the door? If so, you're not alone. Many cat parents have experienced this odd, sometimes icky, behavior. But what’s really behind it?

Let’s break it down from a pet parent’s perspective with insights from Dogs On The Run to help you understand—and manage—this primal habit.

Your Cat Isn’t Hungry—They're Hardwired to Hunt

No, Fluffy isn’t trying to tell you she’s starving. Cats are natural-born hunters. Even after over 10,000 years of domestication, our cozy couch cats still carry the instincts of their wild ancestors. Hunting is simply part of who they are.

As Dr. Stephanie Liff, a veterinarian, points out, this behavior is less about food and more about instinct. Whether your cat eats the prey or not, the drive to stalk, pounce, and catch is deeply ingrained.

So…Why Bring It to You?

One of the most accepted theories is that your cat sees you as part of their family—more specifically, like a giant, helpless kitten. In the wild, mama cats bring home prey to teach their young how to eat and hunt. When your cat plops a bird on your doormat, they might be saying: “Hey, you're part of my crew—and I’m here to take care of you.”

That’s not an insult—it’s actually a compliment! Your cat feels safe, bonded, and secure enough to share their prize.

It Might Also Be a Safety Move

Some cats simply feel more comfortable eating at home than in the wild. Your house is their sanctuary. It's where they can relax and enjoy their “meal” without interruptions. In that sense, they’re not just gifting you—they’re choosing your home as their safe dining space.

Not All Cats Are Hunters—And That’s Okay

Not every cat is a natural-born hunter. A 2023 study found that personality plays a huge role. Cats that are bold, active, and a bit dominant tend to hunt more. Shy or social cats? They’re usually less interested in stalking prey.

Where you live also makes a difference. Cats in rural areas have more opportunities to chase wildlife than city cats do. So if you're seeing fewer “presents,” it might just be your cat’s personality or environment.

*

Want to cut back on the dead critters showing up at your door? Here are a few helpful hints from Dogs On The Run:

• Keep your cat indoors: The simplest and safest solution.

• Limit access to prey: If you have bird feeders, try placing them higher or farther from places your cat can reach.

• Provide enrichment: Satisfy their hunting drive with toys that mimic prey—feathers, wand toys, treat puzzles, and interactive playtime work wonders.

Helping Nature—and Your Cat

Allowing cats to roam and hunt doesn’t just affect your doorstep—it impacts local ecosystems. Domestic cats are responsible for killing billions of birds and small mammals each year. In some areas, they’ve contributed to the extinction of native species.

Keeping your cat inside doesn’t just protect wildlife—it protects your cat too. Wild prey can carry diseases like parasites, rabies, or avian flu. If your kitty does go outside, make sure they’re vaccinated and regularly checked by your vet.

Final Thoughts from Dogs On The Run

So, when your cat brings home a “gift,” don’t take it the wrong way. It’s a sign of trust and affection—and a nod to their wild roots. But if you’d rather avoid these grisly tokens of love, managing their environment and offering fun, safe alternatives can go a long way.

Your cat isn’t just being weird—they’re being a cat. And now, as a savvy pet parent, you’ve got the tools to understand them just a little bit better.

Want more helpful tips like this? Stick with Dogs On The Run—your go-to for pawsitive pet parenting advice! 🐾